📋 Tender Overview
Chief Supreme Judge Carlos Arias Lazarte highlights legal contributions from prominent professionals and academics during hearing.The Transitory Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court, chaired by Judge Carlos Arias Lazarte, left five cassation appeals to vote that will allow this court to establish jurisdictional criteria on the shared possession of children and adolescents (NNA), stipulated by Law No. 31590.
During the hearing, the lawyers of some of the procedural parties presented their claims, as well as four Peruvian specialists and one Spanish specialist participated as amicus curiae (friends of the Court), who expressed their technical and scientific opinions on the subject.
The appeals submitted for debate are identified with the numbers 60-2024/Moquegua, 152-2026/Lambayeque, 530-2026/Ayacucho, 790-2026/Huaura and 1054-2026/Apurimac.
Professionals and academics Benjamin Aguilar Llanos, Jorge Valencia Corominas, Teresa Elizabeth Maquilon, Alexander Camus Cubas and the Spanish Viviana Santillan Santa Cruz intervened as amicus curiae.
Shared ownership is the perfect example of how Law is not a static science but a living discipline that evolves alongside society and new family dynamics, said Arias Lazarte at the beginning of the hearing.
He maintained that the Supreme Court, through this public hearing, opens the doors to citizens to make transparent how the jurisprudence that impacts peoples lives is constructed.
The debate on shared ownership invites us to reflect as a society on co-responsibility in raising children, breaking traditional gender stereotypes and opting for more equitable families, even in separation, he highlighted.
He added that citizen trust is the greatest asset as a justice system and that public hearings constitute the mechanism to demonstrate that the Judiciary acts with transparency, impartiality, predictability and deep respect for human dignity.
ACADEMY AND JUDICATURE
For her part, the titular supreme judge Emilia Bustamante Oyague, a member of the court, expressed that in her career as a magistrate she has had the experience of hearing various files on the matter under debate, and she always sought to adequately obtain the opinion of the boy and girl in judicial conflict.
We are judges, not enemies of father or mother, that is not our role, and with the purpose of establishing some lines of jurisprudential doctrine, this hearing means a great effort to also seek a dialogue between the academy and the judiciary, that is the objective, he indicated.
Meanwhile, in his intervention, amicus curiae Benjamin Aguilar Ramos expressed his disagreement with the word tenure used in Law No. 31590, which regulates shared ownership, since he considers that this term is associated with having a thing with him.
What is under discussion is not a thing but a human person, we should leave that word aside and perhaps better use shared coexistence or the coexistence of the boy, girl, adolescent with the father or mother, he remarked.
Meanwhile, Valencia Corominas commented that the boy or girl should be with the parent who makes it easier for the other to see him or her; and if one of them prevented the other, the latter would not be able to exercise possession.
The specialist mentioned that the father and mother must have the ability to evaluate, discuss and establish rules jointly based on the best interests of their child.
For her part, Family Law professor, Elizabeth Maquilon Acevedo, expressed that Law No. 31590 seems to favor parents who dispute custody, but not the children themselves.
He expressed his concern about the excessive judicialization of intimate family problems and even more so of the relationship between parents and their children, whether they are boys, girls or adolescents.
It is a concern because we are involving children in going to court and taking a position against their parents, when these children love both, he indicated.
COPARENTAL RESPONSIBILITY
Meanwhile, Camus Cubas also expressed his disagreement with the expression shared possession, and rather considered that the most appropriate thing would be to speak of joint co-parental responsibility on the part of the parents.
Then, the members of the court requested comments from specialists and academics on certain points of the topic under debate, which were answered by them.
Finally, Arias Lazarte expressed his gratitude to each of the amicus curiae for the contributions made and presented them with a diploma of recognition for their participation.
In addition to Arias Lazarte and Bustamante Oyague, the aforementioned panel also includes Judge Carmen Julia Cabello Matamala, as well as judges Jose Wilfredo Diaz Vallejos and Henry Antonino Huerta Saenz.
Lima, June 6, 2026