Energy, Power and Electrical

Slovenia Stand Transparent Tender

📄 Tender ID: 509846476 📅 Published: 25 Oct 2024

📋 Tender Overview

Since its inception, the Ministry of Environment, Climate and Energy has been committed to a transparent and inclusive debate on the future of energy supply in Slovenia, and it has been working that way. The Ministry has never hidden anything, the accusations that we did not publish Mr. Mervar's analysis due to the interest in concealing information that would be relevant for decision-making on the JEK 2 project are unfounded.

Since its inception, the Ministry of Environment, Climate and Energy has been committed to a transparent and inclusive debate on the future of energy supply in Slovenia, and it has been working that way. This is evidenced by the versions of the NEPN that have been published to date and the expert basis that was the basis for their preparation. NEPN includes both scenarios, in addition to RES + JE, there is also a 100 percent RES scenario, including all foreseen macroeconomic, energy, technical and economic assessments. It is prepared with the cooperation of reputable professional institutions, according to an internationally comparable methodology, and follows the guidelines provided by the European regulation for the preparation of all NEPN, not only the Slovenian one.

The circumstances of the preparation of the author's analysis of Mr. Mervar
From the point of view of an inclusive and transparent discussion, the Ministry of the Environment, Climate and Energy, at the initiative of non-governmental organizations, wanted to work out some additional aspects of the 100 percent RES scenario NEPN in the summer. For cooperation, we personally contacted Mr. Aleksandar Mervar, director of Eles, who we asked to prepare a technical analysis for the ministry on how much additional capacity would be needed for wood biomass, biogas, geothermal energy and storage tanks (that is, resources that can perform supply also with broadband electricity) to be able to cover the difference that this nuclear scenario makes. It is therefore about identifying additional needs in which we would have to invest if we did not invest in JEK2. We are publishing the letter in its entirety.

The author's analysis of Mr. Mervar had a confidential mark until last Sunday, which was withdrawn at our initiative. The purpose of withdrawing the label was so that the ministry could share the document with a wider circle of employees, and give it to some other relevant stakeholders, such as the Jožef Štefan Institute, for review and opinion.

The content of the analysis prepared by Mr. Mervar
Mr. Mervar prepared the author's analysis, where it focused mainly on the comparison of financial - economic aspects, not technical ones. He prepared 11 scenarios and compared them with each other, and at the same time it is worth emphasizing the difference between the scenario he calls "without JEK2 and without NEK", which is the closest approximation to the scenario called "100 percent renewable energy" in NEPN, and between what Mr. Mervar calls the "100 percent RES scenario", which assumes that gas is not used for supply as a transitory source, and that all supply is always from sources produced in the territory of Slovenia.

In the analysis, Mr. Mervar notes that the cheapest scenario is the scenario without JEK2 and without NEK1 after 2043, which is also the closest approximation to the NEPN 100% RES scenario. This envisages the use of natural gas in a transitional period, which in the following decades will gradually be replaced by increasing the share of renewable gases, and of course also the use of an integrated internal market. The results are comparable to the NEPN results, which clearly show that we cannot ensure a competitive supply of electricity in Slovenia with solar power plants alone and, as a result, the significantly larger capacities of storage tanks and investments in the network, and that the solution must be found in a balanced mix of different renewable energy technologies. also gas ones.

The author has been completely free in the use of economic assumptions and in his estimates he also takes into account the costs of operation and maintenance.

Response to allegations of concealment
Allegations that the ministry did not publish the analysis due to the interest in concealing information that would be relevant for decision-making on the JEK 2 project are unfounded. The document could in no way significantly influence the referendum campaign, which has not even started yet. The referendum would also not decide on potential scenarios for Slovenia's energy supply, but on the implementation of a concrete project, the information from the aforementioned analysis could not contribute to better informing citizens about the JEK 2 project. i. the long-term nuclear scenario is realized even without JEK2, e.g. by extending the life of NEK1 until 2063 or by building small modular reactors. Therefore, we reject the accusations that the current non-publication of the document, which is the author's analysis of one energy expert and has not been peer-reviewed, could significantly improve citizens' information about the JEK2 project, since it was not even fundamentally intended for that.

Further steps
The Ministry of the Environment, Climate and Energy intended to publish the technical analysis from the very beginning, since the reason for its preparation came precisely from the public. Unfortunately, according to our assessment, the analysis does not yet include precise information that would give answers with how much additional capacity could be sufficient to replace the nuclear source. It would be more appropriate to wait until full information is available before publication, but we are now responding to calls for publication. However, Mr. Mervar's analysis itself is an excellent and very welcome analytical contribution to the continuation of the public debate.

🔍 Key Information

📄
Tender Reference No.
509846476
📅
Publication Date
25 Oct 2024
🌐
Sector
Energy, Power and Electrical
📝
Notice Type
News
📍
Location
Slovenia

📁 Documents & Downloads

No documents found

🏷️ CPV

No CPV found

Need help with this bid?

Our bid experts can help you find, evaluate & win more tenders.

🎧 Talk to Bid Expert
🕒 Submission deadline
0
days remaining · 25 Oct 2024
🔔 Set Alert

🧭 Quick Facts

Authority N/A
Country Slovenia
State / UT N/A
Tender Type Procurement News
Currency N/A
Similar Tenders
Loading similar tenders…