📋 Tender Overview
The specialized creditor organizations are unhappy with the multiple increase in the size of court state fees, the provisions of which were introduced for the second reading into the bill on tax amendments. The Association of Russian Banks and the National Association of Professional Collection Agencies emphasize in letters to the Ministry of Economic Development, the Ministry of Finance and the specialized committee of the State Duma: in its current form, the document will limit access to justice for low-income Russians. In addition, the bill will force banks and microfinance organizations to increase the cost of loans and credits, and manufacturers of goods and service providers to increase prices. Finally, due to high fees, it will become easier for creditors to initiate mass bankruptcies of debtors themselves, and collectors will lose interest in working with bad debts.
Industry associations of banks and collectors have criticized the multiple increase in the size of court fees. Forbes has reviewed a letter from the Association of Russian Banks (ARB) to the Ministry of Economic Development and an appeal from the National Association of Industry Collection Agencies (NAPCA) to the State Duma Committee on Budget and Taxes. In both documents, they ask to review a number of provisions of the draft law "On Amendments to Parts One and Two of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation and Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation on Taxes and Fees." The letters refer to provisions that significantly increase the size of court fees. They appeared in the version of the draft law for the second reading, which is scheduled for July 23.
The ABR and NAPCA confirmed that the letters were sent. The drafters of the bill justify the multiple increase in the amount of fees by the intention to find sources of replenishment of the federal budget, while they rely on judicial statistics of previous years, it is noted in both letters. For example, in 2023, out of 23.5 million court orders, more than 52% were for collection under loan agreements and loans, and this share has been growing since 2021, the ABR writes. At the same time, it is not taken into account that if the proposed fees are introduced, sending such documents to the courts will become economically unprofitable for creditors, the NAPCA letter says. And for low-income citizens, as well as those who find themselves in a difficult life situation (for example, debtors or bankrupts), the amount of the fee may become an unbearable financial burden, the ABR points out.
"The average monthly nominal accrued salary in Russia by the end of 2023 was about 75,000 rubles, and the size of the insurance pension was just over 23,000. Thus, the new duties will be prohibitive for many Russians, both plaintiffs and defendants. They will not be able to afford to go through three courts. For creditors, the proposed duties will mean new expenses, and collecting small debts will become ineffective. They will take all this into account in their pricing policy," warns ABR Vice President Sergey Klimenko.
Forbes sent inquiries to the Ministry of Economic Development, the Ministry of Finance, and the relevant State Duma committee. The Ministry of Economic Development and the Budget and Tax Committee told Forbes that they had not yet received any letters. The Ministry of Finance had not responded to the inquiries at the time of publication.
What are creditors afraid of?
In its letter, the ABR draws attention to the significant increase in state fees when applying to the court. For example, when filing a property claim in a court of general jurisdiction with a claim price of 20,000 rubles, the state fee is now 800 rubles, and will be 4,000; with a claim price of 10 million rubles, you will have to pay 120,000 rubles instead of the current 60,000. The cost of considering claims in the order of summary proceedings will also increase, the ABR continues. Currently, the maximum amount of the state fee is 9,000 rubles, and if accepted, it will cost 10,000 rubles and above. Taken together, the proposed increases will create financial barriers for borrowers and creditors, the association believes. In addition, paradoxical situations may arise. For example, when demanding from the defendant within 1,000-5,000 rubles, the state fee will exceed the amount of the debt several times.
ABR, firstly, proposes to leave the duties at current levels and to relieve the judicial system in other ways. For example, to allow banks to issue bank orders that will have the force of an enforcement document. According to the authors of the letter, such a practice should be used for cases of extrajudicial collection for debts not exceeding 500,000 rubles. In this case, banks will be able to immediately send their decision to the bailiffs along with a certificate on the debtor's account.
Secondly, the ABR warned of a possible surge in borrower bankruptcies if new state fees are introduced. For example, if the maximum fee values ??for disputes in courts of general jurisdiction and in arbitration disputes are cancelled, it will be easier for creditors to pay a fee of 100,000 rubles to initiate bankruptcy of a debtor than to enter into an already started procedure or collect a debt in a lawsuit, where the fees are higher, the authors of the letter note. In addition, the bill provides for a twenty-fold increase in the amount of state fees for individuals and a five-fold increase for legal entities for filing appeals, and a thirty-fold and six-fold increase when applying to a cassation court. For citizens who have defaulted on a loan, this will become an additional financial burden and provoke a surge in bankruptcies, they believe.