📋 Tender Overview
Comptrollers Office notified the Regional Government of Piura of the report. The General Comptrollers Office has noted deficiencies and possible cost overruns, exceeding one million soles, in the technical file of the project to improve and expand the water service of the canal irrigation system in the Hualtaco IV sector of the Tambogrande district. For this reason, it recommended that the Piura Regional Government take prompt action.
According to the Control Milestone Report No. 24241-2024-CG/GRPI-SCC, an increase in the cost of materials corresponding to the item referring to the canal lining was detected, which generates a possible adverse consequence for the entity of S/ 1,138,563.50.
In this sense, there would be an inconsistency in the quantities of materials recorded in the unit cost analysis of the technical file compared to the quantities verified by the control commission based on the mix design and the plans of the same file. The materials needed for this item amounted to S/ 25.22, but the entity considered a cost of S/ 48.63. This oversizing influenced the increase in the unit price of the aforementioned item.
Additionally, the compacted fill item with borrowed material for the canal does not present technical characteristics of granular fill material, which puts the quality and useful life of the project at risk. This fact generates a possible adverse consequence for the entity of S/ 2,644,344.76.
Likewise, it was shown that the price of the dump truck, recorded in the budget of the technical file, is not supported. This situation causes a possible overvaluation of the cost of the work and, therefore, of the reference value of the selection procedure.
The project
Channel 21.5 of the irrigation project of the work belongs to the hydraulic infrastructure of the San Lorenzo system and originates from the Tablazo canal that was built in the second stage of this irrigation project. It covers a total area of approximately 379.50 hectares with irrigation license and directly benefits dozens of user families, settled in the town of CP 12, Yoque Yupanqui, Jose Olaya and surrounding areas of the Tambogrande district.
In 2019, the entity approved the technical file with an investment cost of S/ 11,182,072.31 and an execution period of 270 calendar days; however, last May, the reformulation of the file was approved with a total investment amount of S/ 16,174,024.01 with prices in effect as of April 2024.
In a previous control service, the Comptrollers Office warned of other adverse situations related to the technical file.