📋 Tender Overview
The property in question, located in the Antonio Raimondi sector, was reportedly recognized as property of Jose Navarro Lopez Torres in 2016. The Public Prosecutors Office requested the dismissal (filing) of the case involving the current governor of Ucayali, Manuel Gambini Rupay; the former regional director of Agriculture, Isaac Huaman Perez; and Nelson Alcibiades Torres Contreras, in the process against them for the crimes of abuse of authority, improper granting of title and generic forgery, all related to alleged irregularities in the award of the Agata Lua property. The hearing to decide on this request will take place on Thursday, September 26, 2024, in the Fourth Preparatory Investigation Court of Coronel Portillo, in charge of Judge Dr. Melina Diaz Acosta.
Alleged facts
The alleged facts date back to 2018, when the regional governor of Ucayali, Manuel Gambini Rupay, and Isaac Huaman Perez, in his role as director of Agriculture, would have issued Regional Executive Resolution No. 118-2018-GRU-GR. This resolution annulled a previous one, Regional Directorial Resolution No. 476-2016-GRU-DRA, which recognized the ownership of the Agata Lua property in favor of Jose Belisario Navarro Lopez Torres. According to the complaint, the annulment was carried out in order to allegedly favor Nelson Alcibiades Torres Contreras, who claimed rights over a plot of land that overlapped the Agata Lua property. This action generated a complaint of abuse of authority and improper granting of title against Gambini Rupay and Huaman Perez, who, according to the aggrieved party, would have acted outside the legal framework by unduly benefiting Torres Contreras.
The property in question, located in the Antonio Raimondi sector, was allegedly recognized as the property of Jose Navarro Lopez Torres in 2016. However, after the resolution granting this recognition was annulled, Torres Contreras managed to obtain a title to the land, which involved the issuance of a new title that, according to the initial fiscal thesis, was granted improperly and outside the established legal procedures. Those involved were accused of having manipulated the administrative processes to allow the irregular award of the land, thus affecting rights previously recognized to Navarro.
In addition, it was specified that Nelson Alcibiades Torres Contreras, in 2002, had committed acts of generic falsehood by manipulating the titling process of his land. According to the complaint, Torres Contreras had placed a fence on the disputed land days before an official inspection, with the aim of ensuring ownership of the Agata Lua property.
Request for dismissal by the Public Prosecutors Office
The request for dismissal is a formal request made by the prosecutor to the judge to end the criminal process, arguing that there is not enough evidence to support an accusation, that the fact investigated is not a crime, or that the criminal action has been extinguished (the time allowed for the State to pursue the crime), among other reasons. If the judge approves it, the case is closed and the accused is free of criminal responsibility.
In the specific case, the request presented by the Third Provincial Corporate Criminal Prosecutors Office of Coronel Portillo is based on the lack of sufficient evidence to support the accusations. Regarding Isaac Huaman, the Public Prosecutors Office argues that, as regional director of Agriculture, he did not have the final authority to issue the resolution, which was the responsibility of the Regional Governor. It was also specified that the resolution in question was signed by the interim regional governor, Mariano Rebasa Alfaro, which would release Gambini Rupay from direct responsibility in the act.
Regarding Nelson Alcibiades Torres Contreras, the charge of generic falsification is based on events that occurred in 2002, when he allegedly manipulated the titling process for the Agata Lua property to ensure his possession. The prosecution maintains that the time elapsed since then has led to the statute of limitations for the crime, in accordance with the provisions of articles 80deg and 83deg of the Penal Code, which establish the statute of limitations for criminal prosecution.
Role of the judge
The Fourth Preparatory Investigation Court must evaluate the arguments presented by the prosecution and decide whether to file the case or continue with the judicial process. If the dismissal is accepted, those under investigation will be exonerated of the charges. Otherwise, the case could move forward to an oral trial, where the alleged irregularities committed would be examined in detail.