📋 Tender Overview
The Comptroller General has detected irregularities in the maintenance service of neighborhood roads of the Provincial Municipality of Moho, resulting in an economic loss of S / 283 601. In addition, three public officials involved have been found to be held criminally and administratively responsible.
The maintenance service of neighborhood roads had been assigned a budget of S / 857 835 and a term of 475 calendar days, and will benefit the entire population of the district of Moho.
According to the Specific Control Report No. 005-2023-2-0185-SCE, corresponding to the period from October 26, 2020 to January 31, 2021, a contractual breach has been detected in the use of granular quarry material, as well as the lack of application of penalties for not performing the proper shaking of said material.
In relation to the batch of granular quarry material used on the road, it was found that stones larger than two inches were used, thus breaching the technical specifications established in the road manuals, terms of reference, contract and current regulations. In addition, said material was placed without making the corresponding shaking.
Likewise, the compaction tests, which are part of the quality control, presented in Monthly Reports Nos. 02 and 03, do not meet the degree of compaction required in the technical specifications and applicable regulations. These tests did not reach 100% of the density obtained in the test called Modified Proctor, which evaluates the compaction of soils or granular materials.
It is important to note that neither the inspector nor those responsible for the user area of the entity noticed or communicated these problems to the municipality. Despite the deficiencies found in the monitoring carried out by the Special Project for Decentralized Transport Infrastructure - Provias Descentralizado on the use of granular material larger than allowed, the necessary actions were not taken to correct these irregularities.
During an inspection visit, it was established that the contractor had not shaken the granular material used in the affirmation layer of a work. This did not meet the established technical and quality standards. However, both the inspector and the officials of the entity allowed this irregularity and did not apply the corresponding penalties to the contractor, and as a result of this, a total economic damage was generated for the entity of S / 283 601.