📋 Tender Overview
The General Comptrollers Office identified alleged criminal liability of three former officials of the El Tallan District Municipality, who participated as full members of a selection committee and favored bidders in two selection procedures for the execution of works on irrigation canals in this town. The amount awarded jointly exceeds one and a half million soles.
According to the Specific Control Report No. 071-2024-2-0454-SCE, in the simplified award procedure for the work to improve the water service in the Seminario - San Martin irrigation canal, it was evident that the selection committee disqualified two bidders for material errors of a correctable nature, without having previously requested the correction of said errors and without considering that the offers of these bidders were lower than the reference value.
The events occurred in 2020. The material errors relate to the assignment of key professional personnel not requested by the bases and the failure to submit the commitments required to meet the qualification requirements. There is no evidence that the committee requested the correction of these errors, which did not affect the content of the bids submitted.
The audit committee determined that, by not allowing the correction, the municipality limited the possibility of accessing a better economic offer, awarding the contract for S/ 935,238.19 (more than S/ 93 thousand above the other offers). Despite this, the contract was awarded to a consortium that submitted the highest offer, contravening the bases and applicable regulations, which affected the purpose of the contract to maximize the use of public resources.
Matorro La Cruz Canal
In 2022, the same selection committee did not accept the offer of a bidder who complied with presenting the unit prices according to the structure established in the work budget and in the corresponding annex. In addition, said offer was lower than the reference value. This simplified award process was for the improvement of the water service for irrigation of the Matorro La Cruz canal, located in the Sinchao hamlet.
Finally, the contract was awarded to a single bidder for S/ 755,553.12, that is, more than S/ 75 thousand difference with the disqualified offer. As a result of the subsequent control, the alleged criminal responsibility of three former officials was identified. For this reason, the Specialized Public Prosecutors Office for Corruption Crimes has been recommended to initiate criminal proceedings against those involved.
Fact
The report was notified to the head of the entity for the corresponding actions and is published in the Control Service Report Search Engine of the institutional portal www.gob.pe/contraloria, for the sake of transparency and access to information.