Law and legal

Norway Evaluation Composition Tender

📄 Tender ID: 507414077 📅 Published: 22 Aug 2024

📋 Tender Overview

The Ministry of Justice and Emergency Preparedness has commissioned KPMG to evaluate the composition of the Court of Appeal in criminal cases. The purpose is to provide the ministry with the necessary knowledge to assess the current arrangement.

After the jury system was discontinued in 2018, the former jury cases are decided by a co-judge with two expert judges and five lay judges (2-5). This is also the composition of the Court of Appeal's processing of other complete appeals and sentencing appeals for offenses with a penalty of more than six years' imprisonment. Previously, these cases were dealt with by a co-judge with three professional judges and four lay judges (3-4).

The task is to gather experiences and views on the current system from the Court Administration, professional judges, lay judges, prosecutors and lawyers with experience of the system. The evaluation will primarily be based on a review of documentation, surveys and interviews. In the assignment, KPMG will examine the following issues:
What is the scope of cases affected by the changes in the composition of the Court of Appeal?
To what extent do the actors believe that the reduction from three to two expert judges has affected the Court of Appeal's ability to handle long-term or complicated cases?
To what extent do the actors believe that the withdrawal of one expert judge during an appeal hearing is a problem?
To what extent do the actors believe that fellow judges add experience and insight that professional judges do not have? To what extent has the change from 3-4 to 2-5 affected this?
To what extent do the actors believe that the reduction from three to two expert judges has affected the Court of Appeal's ability to decide procedural questions that arise during the appeal hearing? In what way do fellow judges contribute to the decision of such procedural questions?
To what extent do the actors believe that the reduction from three to two professional judges has affected the Court of Appeal's ability to decide civil claims in criminal cases? In what way do fellow judges contribute to the decision of such questions?
What do the actors perceive to be the contribution, role and influence of co-judges in sentencing appeals?
What do the actors think are the practical consequences (both positive and negative) of the current composition of two expert judges and five lay judges in the Court of Appeal?
What do the players think of the current composition? Which arrangement do the players prefer?
The evaluation will be carried out in the period June–December 2024.

🔍 Key Information

📄
Tender Reference No.
507414077
📅
Publication Date
22 Aug 2024
🌐
Sector
Law and legal
📝
Notice Type
News
📍
Location
Norway

📁 Documents & Downloads

No documents found

🏷️ CPV

No CPV found

Need help with this bid?

Our bid experts can help you find, evaluate & win more tenders.

🎧 Talk to Bid Expert
🕒 Submission deadline
0
days remaining · 22 Aug 2024
🔔 Set Alert

🧭 Quick Facts

Authority N/A
Country Norway
State / UT N/A
Tender Type Procurement News
Currency N/A
Similar Tenders
Loading similar tenders…