📋 Tender Overview
The Federal Regional Court of the 4th Region (TRF4) restored the environmental embargo imposed by Ibama to a real estate development in a sensitive area of the coast of Santa Catarina.
The decision responds from the Federal Attorney General (AGU) and the Federal Prosecutors Office (MPF) to suspend the injunction that authorized the continuity of a 23-hectare subdivision in Praia Grande, a resort located in the municipality of Governador Celso Ramos (SC).
According to the case file, the terrain covers permanent preservation areas, where there is record of endangered fauna and flora species.
The company had obtained injunction in a writ of mandamus to suspend the effects of the embargo, claiming to have valid licenses issued by the Santa Catarina Environment Institute (IMA).
According to the Federal Regional Prosecutors Office of the 4th Region (PRF4), AGU unit that represented Ibama in the case, the municipality found, based on technical reports and surveys carried out at the site, that the company presented to the state agency documents with false information. The analysis pointed to willful change in vegetation typology and omission on the existence of protected areas and threatened species.
These irregularities allowed improper authorizations for vegetation suppression, constituting very serious infraction, provided for in article 69-A of Law 9.605/98, with a penalty of imprisonment and fine, said federal prosecutor Giorgia Sena Martins, who acted in the case.
She also pointed out that the writ of mandamus is an inappropriate procedural instrument to address a controversy with high factual and legal complexity.
Irreversible environmental damage
In its appeal, PRF4 detailed the severity of environmental degradation verified on site, involving fragile ecosystems such as dunes, restinga, lagoons, bathing, springs and primary vegetation of the Atlantic Forest.
Restingas, for example, function as natural barriers against advancement of sea, protecting the coast of erosion and storms, and housing endemic and threatened species. The dunes are essential for the stability of beaches and maintenance of unique ecosystems, serving as shelter for species adapted to extreme conditions. Wet areas such as interdunar and interdunar areas and Battered, they play a crucial role in reloading aquifers, pollutant filtering and preserving aquatic and terrestrial biodiversity. The centenary vegetation of the Atlantic Forest represents an invaluable genetic heritage, whose natural regeneration can take decades or even centuries, explained the prosecutor.
The Prosecutors Office also argued that the granting of the injunction represented a reversal of values, since a possible economic damage would be compensable, while environmental damage would be difficult and time consuming recovery.
The embargo aims to avoid irreversible damage to the environment. This is not merely technical divergence, but a finding of evident illegality and concrete risk, said the prosecutor.
Initially, the Rapporteur of the case in TRF4 rejected the IBAMA request. However, after further analysis caused by the MPF interlocutory appeal - which reiterated the arguments of the federal authority - the magistrate reconsed her decision. He concluded that the lower court injunction had a satisfactory nature and could have difficult effects.
With the new decision, the injunction was suspended. The Ibama embargo remains valid until the final judgment of the writ of mandamus.
Reference Process: 5011606-14.2025.4.04.0000/SC and 5014645-19.2025.4.04.0000/SC
Special Advisory of Social Communication of AGU