📋 Tender Overview
Federal Minister of Justice Dr. Marco Buschmann explains:
"With the law, we are creating legal regulations that expressly define the limits of the external ministerial right to issue instructions to the public prosecutor's offices. At the same time, we are creating transparency regulations with regard to the issuing of instructions. In this way, we achieve more legal certainty, enable better traceability and can counteract the "bad appearance" of political influence. We are thus increasing trust in our rule of law"
In particular, the draft bill provides:
The draft contains an amendment to Section 146 of the Courts Constitution Act (Gerichtsverfassungsgesetz – GVG), to which two new paragraphs are added. These regulate the conditions under which instructions are permissible and which requirements are to be met in order to increase transparency. In addition, it counters the criticism of the European Court of Justice, which criticized the lack of regulations regarding the prerequisites and form of the right to issue instructions.
Limits of the right to issue instructions:
An external or internal instruction on the management of the case, i.e. with regard to the actual investigative acts, is only permissible in the following cases:
to prevent unlawful decisions,
insofar as there is a margin of discretion in fact or in law,
if the public prosecutor's office has discretion on a question.
The constellations reflect the existing legal principles and expressly set out the requirements for the admissibility of instructions.
The regulations refer to both the external (ministerial) right to issue instructions and the internal right to issue instructions within the public prosecutor's office, i.e. from the public prosecutor's office to the public prosecutor's office.
Transparency regulation with regard to the external (ministerial) right to issue instructions:
The instructions should be given and justified in text form for documentation. The text form is respected if the instructions are given by e-mail.
An exceptional provision allows the instruction to be confirmed and substantiated on the following day at the latest if, for special reasons, the instruction could only be given orally or without justification.
The text form and the statement of reasons requirements are intended to facilitate the comprehensibility of instructions and to protect the instructing person from hasty instructions.
The draft bill was sent to the states and associations today and published on the BMJ website. Interested parties now have the opportunity to comment until 7 June 2024. The statements are published on the BMJ website.