Law and legal

Germany Bavaria Continues Tender

📄 Tender ID: 507738557 📅 Published: 30 Aug 2024

📋 Tender Overview

In the autumn, the German Bundestag plans to debate the federal government's draft law regulating the use of undercover investigators and confidential informants. The Bavarian State Ministry of Justice continues to reject the law, in broad agreement with the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior and the Bavarian courts and public prosecutors. Bavaria's Minister of Justice Georg Eisenreich : "Our constitutional state must protect citizens. The traffic light government is doing the opposite with this law. It wants to more strictly limit investigative options that also have an impact on protection against extremist attacks. Extremists, clan criminals and human traffickers are increasingly isolating themselves. The use of informants has proven in many cases to be an effective means - often the only one - in the fight against extremism and organized crime. Undercover informants provide important insider information in the fight against crime. The new regulation makes the use of informants more difficult and threatens to significantly burden an important investigative measure for uncovering criminal structures."

The minister : "The use of informants in criminal proceedings on the basis of current law has been recognised for many years by the highest courts and also by the Federal Constitutional Court. There is legal certainty and legal clarity, so there is no need for regulation." In this respect, it is not understandable why reference is being made to findings from the NSU investigative committees to justify the need for regulation. This simply did not concern the use of informants in criminal proceedings. The minister : "Against the background of the ongoing danger posed by terrorist crimes, I have no understanding of the position of the Federal Minister of Justice. The words of the traffic light government must be followed by actions. This is precisely not the case with this law."

To date, the Code of Criminal Procedure has only provided an explicit regulation for undercover investigators, ie police officers who carry out undercover investigations over a longer period of time under a false identity (so-called cover). According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice and the Federal Constitutional Court, the use of informants (ie private individuals who provide information to the law enforcement authorities) can be based without further ado on the general investigation clause of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The legal reform provides for the following strict conditions for the use of informants:

Judicial reservation: The use of informants must now be ordered by the court at the request of the public prosecutor. Eisenreich : "The draft law is based on a completely unfounded mistrust in the work of the law enforcement authorities and in particular in the investigative tool of informants. Judicial reservation would require an unforeseeable additional effort in the required individual permits and would place an unnecessary further burden on our courts."

Strict rules for core area protection : According to the draft law, undercover agents should no longer enter into particularly close relationships with target persons. Eisenreich : "From our investigators' point of view, this is unrealistic. How is an undercover agent supposed to gain access to the inner circle of criminal clans or human trafficking rings, for example, without the closest personal contacts?"

Documentation requirements: The draft law requires verbatim transcripts of the conversations between the informant leaders and their informants. Eisenreich : "Reproducing the verbatim transcripts or even revealing the meeting point with the investigators could lead to informants being exposed and put in danger."

Maximum deployment time: Reliable informants often need years to work their way up to the hierarchical levels of a criminal structure that are of interest to investigators. The deployment time for informants is now to be limited to ten years. Eisenreich : "The reform could mean that particularly reliable informants with access to the highest criminal circles will no longer be available in the future simply because of an abstract deadline."

Minister Eisenreich : "I already pointed this out in the Bundesrat in April: This draft law is unrealistic, puts obstacles in the way of prosecutors and unnecessarily burdens our already heavily used courts. I strongly recommend that the Federal Minister of Justice visit the site and take a look at the practice."

🔍 Key Information

📄
Tender Reference No.
507738557
📅
Publication Date
30 Aug 2024
🌐
Sector
Law and legal
📝
Notice Type
News
📍
Location
Germany

📁 Documents & Downloads

No documents found

🏷️ CPV

No CPV found

Need help with this bid?

Our bid experts can help you find, evaluate & win more tenders.

🎧 Talk to Bid Expert
🕒 Submission deadline
0
days remaining · 30 Aug 2024
🔔 Set Alert

🧭 Quick Facts

Authority N/A
Country Germany
State / UT N/A
Tender Type Procurement News
Currency N/A
Similar Tenders
Loading similar tenders…