📋 Tender Overview
The draft proposal on the environmental objectives of water management and deviations from them provides a good understanding of the background, legal situation and proposed change. The estimates of the bill have highlighted the uncertainties related to them. The environmental impacts have been sufficiently assessed, but the effects of the deviation on aquatic ecosystems and recreational use of waters could be illustrated through examples.
New provisions on the environmental objectives of water status would be added to the Act on the Organisation of Water Resources and Marine Management to be applied in the permit procedure. A new permit requirement would be added to the permit requirements of the Environmental Protection Act and the Water Act based on the interpretation confirmed by the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union of the binding nature of the environmental objectives of water management in permit consideration.
The Economic Policy Council considers that the legislative proposal is, for the most part, well prepared. But for those less familiar with the subject, it would be easier if the current legal situation, key scientific concepts and the proposed amendment were illustrated, for example, with a diagram or table. In addition, the proposal could illustrate, by way of example, what the prohibition of impairment means in practice from the trader's point of view. This would better illustrate how the derogation procedure would change.
According to the legislative proposal, the proposal would allow deviations from the environmental objectives of water management under certain conditions. To a limited extent, this derogation could increase the adverse impacts of new projects on water. The legislative proposal should explain in more detail what kind of risks harmful water impacts may pose to aquatic ecosystems and recreational use of waters.
The statement of the Legislative Evaluation Council has been issued on the draft government proposal to Parliament for acts amending the Act on the Organisation of Water and Marine Management, the Environmental Protection Act and the Water Act (project number: YM043:00/2022Link to another site), which the Ministry of the Environment made available to the Council by email on 4.4.2023.
The Economic Policy Council considers that the draft government proposal meets well the requirements of the impact assessment guidelines for legislative drafting. The Economic Policy Council recommends that the draft government proposal be supplemented in accordance with the Council's statement before the government proposal is submitted.