📋 Tender Overview
Tariff impacts that fall on energy consumers due to compensation to wind and solar generators due to production limitations were the theme of the Public Hearing held by the Infrastructure Commission (CI) on Tuesday (30). Among other points, the hearing participants pointed out possible threats to the national electrical system and defended investments for the evolution of this electric matrix.
They debated the restriction of energy production - the shortness or constrained off - which is the mechanism used by the National System Operator (ONS) when there are operational limits on the power grid or other external reasons that prevent the functioning of the power plant. In this case, the plant could produce electricity, but there is no way to function by limitations in the network, such as lack of infrastructure to transport energy, or low demand, among other reasons. The wind or solar plant, even if able to function, is required to interrupt its production. And so it is reimbursed.
System control
The director general of the ONS, Marcio Rea, said that the agency manages the energy surpluses, noting that the operation of the national electrical system has become more complex in recent years. Increasing intermittent energy sources, he said, resulted in challenges such as excess supply especially during the day from 9am to 4pm.
-Today, the ONS has no technical-regulatory mechanisms to make this regulation, and we see an increasingly challenging scenario for the future. Projections indicate that by 2029, only 45% of the installed generation capacity of the country will be under the coordination of ONS. This scenario reinforces the urgency of debates, seeking to balance responsibilities and ensure operational efficiency - explained.
Advisor to the Director General of the National Electric Energy Agency (Aneel), Julio Cesar Rezende Ferraz pointed out that the incentive for wind and solar generation, observed in recent years, has resulted in financial problems. According to him, some generators who have had these losses argue that costs are passed on. Another problem, he said, has technical character, as this intermittent energy supply is not controllable and prevents maintaining the safety of the electrical system.
- Twice, only this year, the ONS has come very close to losing its ability to control the system. This is not resolved solely and exclusively with philosophical discussions, but philosophical discussions are important to prevent the problem from getting worse. There is no silver bullet, but we will need to be reasonable to understand the various points of view and identify the most reasonable solution for all of Brazil.
Waste
Representative of the Brazilian Association of Electric Energy Generating Companies (ABRAGE), Marisete Pereira, stated that the issue has generated major concerns because the expansion of the energy matrix less than the defendant, and yet in a disorderly way. According to her, the national electrical system became deficient. Between 2022 and 2024, losses with generation cuts resulted in unacceptable waste in a country that seeks safety and sustainability, in a context of energy transition.
- We have a disordered expansion because the deranges in this expansion have resulted in cuts of generation. And all this brings damage to consumers. It is necessary to treat the effects of the cuts that the country has already suffered and develop a solution to avoid its aggravation in the future - he said.
Marisete suggested measures that may result in a balanced solution of the problem, such as valuing hydroelectric generation for its consumer benefits and system safety; rebalance supply and demand in a coordinated and structural manner from the perspective of the matrix; Optimize the use of all sources, fostering competition and safety to the system; and align price formation with the reality of the operation, with efficient economic signs and adequate compensation for the services provided.
Energy cuts
CEO of the Brazilian Association of Independent Electric Energy Producers (Apine), Rui Altieri stated that the shortable generates financial impacts for all sources of generation, disrupts contracts, expands charges, creates uncertainty for investors and compromises the financial viability of the enterprises. According to him, the repetition of these episodes reinforces the urgency of regulatory adjustments. He defended the model revision and the apportionment of cuts between the population.
-By 2025, the shortness already exceeds 20% of the energy produced, consolidating itself as a structural problem. The distributed micro and mini -generation [MMGD], supported by subsidies, grows in a disorderly manner, expanding the generation cuts at certain times of the day. This causes the need to use thermal plants in other hours, when there is no sun, pressing system costs further.
According to the director of the Department of Sectoral Policies of the Ministry of Mines andEnergy (MME), Frederico de Araujo Teles The portfolio understands the need for planning studies for the expansion of transmission and said that a bid for the installation of compensators in the Northeast is underway, which should result in decreases in supply cuts.
- Other planning issues should be resolved in early 2026: More expansions to be foreseen in the grant plan, mitigation analysis and improvement identification for system expansion. We are also dealing with the export of electricity, especially for Argentina and Uruguay, which can also alleviate the cuts of generation.
Account
The meeting was led by the committee chairman, Senator Marcos Rogerio (PL - RO). For him, it is necessary to evaluate the contractual impacts, the tariff charges and the consequences of the shortable. The senator considered that Brazil encouraged the expansion of renewable energy, but this also represents a challenge, as subsidies to these sources weigh on the energy bill paid by the population. Due to the complexity of the theme