📋 Tender Overview
The Commission for Transparency, Inspection and Control (CTFC) approved on Tuesday (6) a proposal that requests the Federal Court of Audit (TCU) an investigation into the performance of the Brazilian Company of Nuclear and Binational Energy Participations (ENBPAR) in an agreement signed with the Paraguayan Company National Electricidad (Andepi) and Itaipu Binacional. The objective is to ascertain the financial and legal impacts of this agreement, which deals with the maintenance of the Itaipu Plant Power Tariff.
The Proposal for Inspection and Control (PFS), presented by Senators Esperidiao Amin (PP-SC) and Dr. Hiran (PP-RR), intends to clarify the terms of an agreement signed in 2024 that maintained the Itaipu Electricity fare for US $ 16.71/KW until 2026, despite the discharge of the plants construction debt in 2023. This discharge was expected to result in the revision of the financial bases of Annex C of the Itaipu Treaty and, consequently, in tariff reduction.
Enabpar, linked to the Ministry of Mines and Energy, and the Ande (responsible for the generation, transmission and distribution of energy in Paraguay) divide the control of Itaipu Binacional.
Debate
The authors of the proposal claim that, instead of starting this process in advance, the Brazilian government directed the resources previously allocated to debt settlement to social and environmental responsibility programs, preventing Brazilian consumers from benefiting from a tariff reduction in the energy generated by Itaipu.
- In 2023, the entire loan set was paid by Brazil to build this epic work. (....) Energy costs, of course, have dropped. The asset is completely solved. What is happening is a very creative thing, Itaipu Binacional has become partner of the government - explained Esperidiao Amin.
-These are resources that should be used to reduce the value of the captive consumer energy bill, in a system that needs to be reevaluated-added Senator Rogerio Marinho (PL-RN).
For Senator Marcos Rogerio (PL-RO), this is a legitimate, necessary and unavoidable discussion.
- Binational does not stop producing, does not stop generating; In fact, it is one of the most important structuring in Brazil. (...) When we talk about this binational Itaipu problem we need to have an understanding of the entire Brazilian electrical system complex. Annex C, which is the core of this debate, needs to move forward - stressed the senator, supporting the proposal.
Senator Jaques Wagner (PT-BA) considered that it is the Senates obligation to oversee; and the company, provide information, to be clarified if there is the good use of public money.
Rapporteur of the matter, Senator Sergio Moro (Uniao-PR) accepted the proposal and highlighted the importance of supervision in the face of the negative of enabbare to disclose the terms of the agreement, even after determination of the Comptroller General of the Union (CGU).
The omission, according to Moro, violates the principle of publicity provided for in article 37 of the Federal Constitution:
- In fact, the lack of commitment to the principle of advertising that will demonstrate by disobeying the decision of the CGU raises suspicions about the legality and sustainability of the agreement signed and prevents Brazilian society from evaluating it, compromising the confidence of the population in public institutions - said the rapporteur.
The report also warns of possible financial losses arising from the agreement, such as the deficit of the Itaipu electricity commercialization account in 2024 and the possibility of contributions from the National Treasury when enabling to cover losses. Among the points to be cleared are: the risks to enab, treasury and consumers; the causes of the 2024 deficit; the possibility of new deficits and their consequences; and the values and criteria for the application of resources in social and environmental programs.
Moro clarified that the PFS does not contradict the previous decision of the Supreme Federal Court (STF), which won direct supervision of TCU to Itaipu Binacional, because the proposal is limited to the audit at Enbpar, a Brazilian public company over which the agency has constitutional competence of control.
Senate Agency (reproduction authorized by citation of the Senate Agency)