📋 Tender Overview
The Attorney General of the Union (AGU) assured, acting in the Federal Regional Court of the 1st Region (TRF1), the application of the 80% legal reserve percentage in exploited areas located in the Legal Amazon, regardless of the date on which environmental exploitation was performed.
The 5th class of TRF1 dismissed the application of the so -called theory of consummated fact in environmental matters. The victory obtained by AGU reaffirms that the acquired right to environmental degradation is not allowed and the impossibility of applying the theory of the perfect legal act or the fact consummated to remove environmental obligations in real estate in the legal Amazon.
The victory was the result of the performance of the Environmental Matter Center of the Final Matter Team of the Federal Regional Attorney of the 1st Region, Unit of the Federal Attorney Generals Office (PGF).
Legal reserve
The Brazilian Institute of Environment and Renewable Natural Resources (Ibama) appealed from a sentence that had applied the perfect legal act to exempt properties in the legal Amazon that had already deforested more than 80% of its area before the edition of the Provisional Measure (MP) No. 2.166-67/2001.
The purpose of this MP, which raised the minimum legal reserve percentage to 80%, is to protect the environmental heritage from the entire community, in line with the principle of social function of property and the fundamental right to the ecologically balanced environment, enshrined in article 225 of the Federal Constitution.
Federal prosecutors maintained that there is no acquired right to environmental degradation, and that the decision of origin contradicted the current environmental legislation and the consolidated jurisprudence, including Precedent 613 of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ), besides facing the public interest and the right of the collectivity to the preservation of the environment.
The 5th class of TRF1 recorded that by exempting the properties that had already deforested more than 80% of its area before the MP edition, based on the notion of perfect legal act, the sentence of the first instance eventually allowed the continuity of environmental degradation situations.
Such an understanding cannot prevail, since the jurisprudence of the higher courts has already consolidated that there is no acquired right to environmental degradation. In this sense, the application of the theory of the fact -consummated fact was expressly prohibited by Precedent 613 of the Superior Court of Justice: It is not allowed the application of the theory of the fact of environmental law , the judge pointed out.
Environmental protection
According to the coordinator of the Environment Center of the Final Team of PRF1, Natalia de Melo Lacerda, the decision reinforces a fundamental understanding for environmental protection in Brazil: there is no acquired right to degradation. The judgment rejects the thesis that deforestation carried out before the edition of the most restrictive rules on legal reserve could be perpetuated based on the so -called perfect legal act. By granting the appeal of Ibama, the court reaffirms that constitutional law to the environmentally balanced environment must prevail over environmental illegality situations, he says.
Thus, the judgment represents an important jurisprudential decision on the duty to comply with current environmental legislation, even in cases of exploitation prior to the norm, in addition to directly applying STJ Precedent 613, contributing to the standardization of jurisprudence and the strengthening of the protection of the legal Amazon.
Ref.: Appeal No. 0007624-29.2005.4.01.3600- TRF-1st Region
Special Advisory of Social Communication of AGU